
36 consumer reports JANUARY
COVER STORY SMART PHONES
Ratings Cell-phone service
Summary Ratings, reflecting all cities surveyed, in order of overall
score. Dierences in score of fewer than five points are not meaningful.
Overview
Standard cell-phone service, involving a
bill at the end of the month, offers smart
phones at a lower price but usually requires
a contract. Prepaid service, either pay-as-
you-go or with a monthly allocation, is
usually contract-free but offers a more
limited, and generally pricier, selection of
smart phones.
TOP CHOICE FOR SMART PHONES
A Verizon Wireless
Among the major carriers, this was the most
satisfying overall and the standout for data
service, an important consideration when
using a smart phone. However, most new
smart phones from major carriers now
connect to highspeed G networks, and
AT &T A offered the least problematic G
service; that makes the carrier worth
considering for a G phone, despite a worse
overall track record than A.
CONSIDER IF AVAILABLE TO YOU
A U.S. Cellular
This carrier has a coverage map that’s
nationwide, but it’s available only to
customers in mostly Midwestern states.
But it is a standout in almost every respect.
SOCIALLY RESPONSIBLE OPTION
A Credo Mobile
This carrier donates to social causes and
offers satisfying enough service. It has
relatively high prices but got stellar
customersupport scores.
BEST CHOICES FOR BASIC NEEDS
A Consumer Cellular
B TracFone
These carriers specialize in nofrills cell
phones and service. A is a nocontract
standard carrier aimed at seniors that offers
standout customer service. B is a prepaid
carrier that offers very inexpensive plans for
minimal phone users. Both had voice service
that was above average.
BUDGET SMARTPHONE STANDOUTS
B Straight Talk
B Virgin Mobile
These nocontract carriers had solid scores.
You’ll generally pay more upfront for the
phone with them than with a standard
carrier, but they offer lowercost unlimited,
voice, text, and data plans and earned high
marks for data.
Think twice about buying that new model early. Upgrading can cost you, especially
if you can’t wait until your two-year contract runs out. Here’s what the big four cell
carriers charge to upgrade to a Samsung Galaxy S III (16GB) halfway through the
contract and at the end of the term. Totals below are for the cost of the phone, typically
with a new two-year contract, plus upgrade fees and penalties.
Can’t wait for that musthave phone?
SEE OUR SMART
PHONES VIDEO
Use your smart phone to
download the RedLaser or
ShopSavvy app and scan
the code for video.
Provider Reader score Survey results Support
0 100
Value
Voice
Text
Data
4G
Phone
Staff knowledge
Issue resolved
A STANDARD
1 Consumer Cellular*
88
&X &X &X &Z
—
&Z &Z &Z
2 U.S. Cellular
85
&X &Z &Z &Z
—
&Z &Z &Z
3 Credo Mobile
76
&C &C &C &X
—
&Z &Z &Z
4 Verizon Wireless
72
&V &X &C &X &C &V &X &X
5 Sprint
66
&V &B &V &C &V &V &C &C
6 T-Mobile
64
&V &B &V &C &C &V &C &C
7 AT&T
62
&B &B &V &V &X &B &C &C
B PREPAID
1 TracFone
82
&X &X &X
— —
&B &V &C
2 Straight Talk
79
&X &C &X &X
—
&B &B &C
3 T-Mobile
76
&X &C &C &C
—
&B &V &V
4 Verizon Wireless
75
&C &X &X
— — —
&C &C
5 Net10
75
&C &C
— — — — — —
6 Virgin Mobile
75
&X &C &C &X
—
&V &C &X
7 MetroPCS
71
&C &C &B &C
— — — —
8 AT&T GoPhone
68
&V &C &C &V
— —
&V &V
*Offers no-contract service, but bills monthly like standard carriers.
Provider Upgrade after Upgrade after
month month
AT&T
Sprint
TMobile
Verizon
5
4
3
2
1
Better Worse
Comments to this Manuals